These books are not twaddle. They are well written, full of imagination, adventure, and fun. Alexander does have one book entry in the 1001 Children's Book book mentioned above and four books mentioned in Great Books for Boys by Kathleen Odean. What level reader are these for? Here's my soapbox moment....
I think that good books, the ones that have timeless tales to tell, can be read by all. I think it is a shame when people think a book is below them. There is value in well written picture books. We have "read" books where they were no words, just illustrations, that made us laugh. That said, I think these books can be for just about any level. Whether read independently or aloud, the stories are there for the enjoying.
There is sorcery in several books, and what could be perceived as a ghost in at least one. If these are things you do not want in your children's reading, then steer clear. If these topics do not bother you, may I suggest going on the adventures Alexander provides? If you have read them, know you and your children can share your enjoyment with us!
Twaddle? Do I feel a Charlotte Mason moment coming on??? :)
ReplyDelete